The value of individuals and the value of nature

The value of individuals and the value of nature

Recents debates within energy ethics have focused on the framework of energy justice. The justice framework is often linked to Western ethical ideas, especially the human rights framework and the ideas of Western individualism. The presentation ongoing debate between human rights and the rights of nature. The analysis highlights the frequent association of human rights with social contract theories, identifying both the strengths and limitations of contractualist individualism.

Presenters
Andreas Spahn
Kind of session / presentation

Our environment is more than nature: a Philosophy of Technology and Capability Approach perspective on human-environment relations

Our environment is more than nature: a Philosophy of Technology and Capability Approach perspective on human-environment relations

In this paper I will explore different notions of ‘environment’ to conduct an analysis of its current explanatory and descriptive power. By utilizing concepts from Philosophy of Technology, concretely from Postphenomenology (Ihde 1990; Verbeek 2006), I aim to illuminate the non-neutral role of everyday tools, media, infrastructure, and technological systems and to highlight their existential and pragmatic relevance for human-environment relations.

Presenters
Margoth Gonzalez Woge
Kind of session / presentation

The Question Concerning Planetary Technology: On Geo-engineering and Sustainable Technologies, Globalisation, and Planetary Limits

The Question Concerning Planetary Technology: On Geo-engineering and Sustainable Technologies, Globalisation, and Planetary Limits

Technology today is increasingly global, in the double sense that it is to be found all around the globe, and that it increasingly depends on global networks of production and information exchange. But what exactly is this globe, and how does technology relate to it? Is the globe on which globalisation occurred in the twentieth century the same planet which geo-engineering and sustainable technologies mean to preserve in the twenty-first century? In this article, we first consider the conditions of possibility for technological globalisation.

Presenters
Ole Thijs
Kind of session / presentation

Beyond Responsible AI Principles: embedding ethics in the system’s lifecycle

Beyond Responsible AI Principles: embedding ethics in the system’s lifecycle

The year 2019 is commonly dubbed the “AI Ethics Year” as it marked a pivotal year in which previous discussions on the impact of AI in society were reflected in many documents endorsed by nations, international institutions, companies, and other organizations. Indeed, Anna Jobin and her colleagues already counted in 2019 more than 80 AI Ethics guidelines (Jobin et al., 2019) , and this number kept increasing in the following years.

Presenters
Juan Ignacio del Valle
Kind of session / presentation

The Dangers of Social Media Epistemic Bubbles

The Dangers of Social Media Epistemic Bubbles

Social media algorithms severely limit our interactions and exposure to other perspectives. However, individuals could still have a responsibility regarding their engagement online. Current literature focuses mostly on echo chambers, algorithmic control, and misinformation. Echo chambers are defined by manipulation whereas epistemic bubbles can be innocently or accidentally exclusive. Instead of algorithms, I consider the role people play in creating social media epistemic bubbles (SMEBs) and the consequential harms on one’s epistemic norms and status as a knower.

Presenters
Hannah Bondurant
Kind of session / presentation

Energy Weapons: Injustices and Energy Socio-Technical Systems in Wartime Ukraine

Energy Weapons: Injustices and Energy Socio-Technical Systems in Wartime Ukraine

Various past and present conflicts suggest that energy can be used as a weapon (Tsafos 2022; LaBelle 2023). Affirming that energy is a weapon can mean and imply different things. It can refer to energy policies, energy and environmental laws and regulations, energy businesses, or energy socio-technical systems such as power plants or transmission lines. It can mean that a specific energy-related issue has been used to either start military hostilities or during warfare. It can indicate intrastate affairs or broader interstate geopolitical equilibria.

Presenters
Giovanni Frigo
Olena Gruba
Tetiana Lysokolenko
Kind of session / presentation

Synergies and Tensions between Environmental Ethics, Climate Ethics, and Research Ethics: A Literature Review of Crosscutting Concepts

Synergies and Tensions between Environmental Ethics, Climate Ethics, and Research Ethics: A Literature Review of Crosscutting Concepts

We live in a time of rapid, global, and long-lasting environmental and technological changes. On the one hand, technological innovation is a major driver of environmental degradation, as illustrated by the pollution caused by agricultural pesticides, ozone layer depletion caused by chlorofluorocarbons, greenhouse gas emissions caused by fossil fuel combustion, and the radioactive waste of nuclear power plants.

Presenters
Michel Bourban
Dominic Lenzi
Kind of session / presentation

The moral weight method: a quantitative approach to methodology in the ethics of technology

The moral weight method: a quantitative approach to methodology in the ethics of technology

Contemporary philosophy of technology has been drawing special attention to the claim that technology is not neutral, but it plays an important role in evaluating moral situations. In line with this premise, some ethicists of technology have developed theories which work under the assumption that ethics should be done in a way that incorporates technological artefacts to ethical assessment. Prominent examples of these theories are Verbeek’s technological mediation theory and Brey’ structural ethics framework. 

Presenters
Haizea Escribano Asensio
Kind of session / presentation

Justice in the Web of Life: Some Considerations

Justice in the Web of Life: Some Considerations

Under the looming specter of mass extinction and escalating climate change, life itself becomes the terrain of various justice struggles. As philosopher Eva von Redecker notes, many recent social justice movements, including climate (“Extinction Rebellion”), feminist (“Ni una menos”), anti-racist (“I can’t breathe”) and Indigenous (“Water is life”) mobilizations explicitly make reference to the politics of life. At the same time, technological developments in the life sciences challenge traditional philosophical accounts of the very meaning of life.

Presenters
Elias König
Kind of session / presentation

Automation and Secrecy in Intelligence Ethics

Automation and Secrecy in Intelligence Ethics

There is established concern that the deployment of autonomous weapons and information systems may lead to ‘moral deskilling’ of military professionals (Vallor 2013, 2015). Most of what has been written about the conditions needed to cultivate martial virtues has focused on kinetic operations, with comparatively little exploring the deskilling of intelligence practitioners and institutions (Meerveld and Lindelauf 2022). 

Presenters
Nicholas Johnston
Kind of session / presentation

(Re-)Engineering For Resilience: Conceptual Engineering As Prevention And Cure

(Re-)Engineering For Resilience: Conceptual Engineering As Prevention And Cure

In recent work on conceptual engineering in the philosophy of technology, conceptual engineering has been proposed as a meaningful way to bridge instances of conceptual disruption. Such proposals predominantly focus on conceptual engineering in terms of curative interventions of conceptual issues.

Presenters
Samuela Marchiori
Joseph Sta. Maria
Kind of session / presentation

Automated Agorae: Religious Violence and Democracy in the Digital Age

Automated Agorae: Religious Violence and Democracy in the Digital Age

This paper utilizes Derrida’s philosophy of tele-technology to examine how social media shapes perceptions of religious violence. Although Derrida did not witness the advent of social media, he already saw how the widespread ownership of television and the accessibility of portable cameras in the late 50s and 60s marked a turning point in our ‘access’ to events all over the world. Today, social media has intensified this access further, as the digitization of our lifeworld provides unparalleled access to free information.

Presenters
Luca Gerard Pompeo Tripaldelli
Kind of session / presentation

Scalar Consciousness: Rethinking Moral Consideration for Digital Minds

Scalar Consciousness: Rethinking Moral Consideration for Digital Minds

If artificial intelligence agents are capable of being conscious or experiencing subjective well-being, it seems plausible that we should offer them moral consideration (Bostrom & Yudkowsky, 2014; Anthis & Harris, 2021). However, the hard problem of consciousness remains a major challenge in understanding the nature of genuine consciousness in AI (Chalmers, 1995).

Presenters
Nick Corvino
Kind of session / presentation

Are automated systems panopticons?

Are automated systems panopticons?

When discussing digital surveillance phenomena, one image persistently comes to mind: the panopticon. In this paper, we aim to connect inquiries into AI's usage across political, economic, and social domains with the panopticon concept. Automated systems, fueled by data, monitor our preferences and desires, subtly shaping them. Through smartphones, computers, or smartwatches, individuals willingly, without knowing it though, carry their surveillance tools. 

Presenters
Adrien Tallent
Kind of session / presentation

Planetary justice and energy (transition) justice: synergies, tensions and blind spots in the literature

Planetary justice and energy (transition) justice: synergies, tensions and blind spots in the literature

The planetary boundary framework defines a ‘safe operating space for humanity’ that requires staying within certain biophysical boundaries of the Earth system (Rockström et al., 2009). Recently, Earth system scientists and social scientists have proposed to complement these biophysical boundaries with ‘just Earth system boundaries’, which encompass three dimensions of justice – intragenerational justice, intergenerational justice, and interspecies justice (the ‘3I approach’) – that are brought together under the concept of ‘planetary justice’ (Gupta et al., 2023).

Presenters
Linde Franken
Kind of session / presentation

Social Media's Responsibility for Disinformation

Social Media's Responsibility for Disinformation

Are social media companies responsible for disinformation? Studies of how algorithms prioritize information suggest that social media significantly contributes to the spread of disinformation. However, the theoretical resources for making sense of responsibility for spreading falsehoods are limited. A testimonial view of responsibility holds that information conduits like Facebook are not responsible. On this view, platforms are merely sources of information, and the proper locus of responsibility is rather with originators (Fricker, 2012).

Presenters
Cayla Clinkenbeard
Kind of session / presentation

Local participation in energy decision-making in the Netherlands: The holy grail or epic fail?

Local participation in energy decision-making in the Netherlands: The holy grail or epic fail?

In recent years, there has been an increasing number of calls for more inclusive local participation in decision-making on local energy infrastructures and projects. This also goes for energy technologies in the Netherlands, as the Dutch Climate policy includes a mandate for municipalities to organise participation in local energy projects. Including stakeholders (instead of shareholders) and their values is important for instrumental and intrinsic reasons. Still, there are important worries concerning local participation in decision-making in energy infrastructures.

Presenters
Nynke van Uffelen
Kind of session / presentation

The New Moral Demands of Experts: Dealing with Normative Uncertainties in Energy Transition

The New Moral Demands of Experts: Dealing with Normative Uncertainties in Energy Transition

There is an increasing awareness that normative issues pervade the energy transition, testified by the popularity of concepts like ‘energy justice’ and the ‘just transition’. In spite of this awareness, experts and practitioners have difficulty relating to the moral implications of their work that are relatively new to them, for three reasons. First, there is a widely held conviction that moral issues are subjective expressions of preference and, as such, do not fit the objective outlook associated with professional expertise.

Presenters
Udo Pesch
Nynke van Uffelen
Behnam Taebi
Kind of session / presentation

Going Beyond the Conventional: The Ethics of the Energy Transition

Going Beyond the Conventional: The Ethics of the Energy Transition

Scholars and practitioners are increasingly paying attention to the normative issues within the ongoing energy transition. For instance, the notion of ‘energy justice’ has become popular in academia, and the ‘just energy transition’ has become a leading thought in the policies of the European Union. Such attention is timely because the energy transition affects many people now and in the future. However, the concepts and approaches taken up in academia and policy are often not subjected to ethical scrutiny (Astola et al., 2022).

Organizers
Nynke van Uffelen
Udo Pesch
Andreas Spahn
Behnam Taebi
Kind of session / presentation

Social (un)freedom: The public sphere in the (in)visibilization society

Social (un)freedom: The public sphere in the (in)visibilization society

In his re-interpretation of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right, Axel Honneth (2014) builds a theory of justice which places the political public sphere as a central component for establishing what he calls ‘social freedom’ (individual autonomy realized in institutions and practices of mutual recognition).

Presenters
Leif Hemming Pedersen
Kind of session / presentation

The Struggle against algorithmic exploitation of recognition-needs

The Struggle against algorithmic exploitation of recognition-needs

Currently, there is significant concern about how AI-driven media platforms feature a logic of reactive and affective interaction, emotional mobilization, and moral outrage rather than lucid, political argumentation. Further, there is rising debate about whether platform companies take advantage of the unrelenting human hunger for bonding, reward, and the bestowal of esteem, exploiting vital needs for recognition as a monetizable vulnerability.

Presenters
Christopher Senf
Kind of session / presentation

Do children pose a challenge to recognition theory? Insights from educational AI

Do children pose a challenge to recognition theory? Insights from educational AI

This talk examines the limitations of recognition theory by arguing that it takes relations between adults as paradigmatic. It challenges how Honneth’s three modes of recognition apply to children and use the example of educational AI to question how technologies should recognize children’s needs, rights and social contributions. First, children may not have yet fully acquired the capacity to recognize their needs. They often require guidance and care to do so and express their experiences of neglect.

Presenters
Michał Wieczorek
Kind of session / presentation

Pattern recognition = patterned identity?

Pattern recognition = patterned identity?

This discussion addresses the question of how being subjected to pattern recognition by AI affects the possibilities of identity formation. Recognition theory explores how a subject (individually and collectively) shapes the self, its sense of dignity and esteem in its relationships with others (Honneth, Taylor). If we replace the ‘Other’ in the recognition relationship with artificial intelligence, questions arise about what we lose and what we gain in terms of social recognition. Is pattern recognition equivalent to patterned identity?

Presenters
Natalia Juchniewicz
Kind of session / presentation

Hegel’s Struggle for Recognition and the Politics of Human-Technology Relations

Hegel’s Struggle for Recognition and the Politics of Human-Technology Relations

Hegel’s analysis of the “struggle for recognition” can be used to understand human-technology relations from a political perspective. This political perspective can consequently help us to appreciate how technologies like robots can come to have a role in political life through our ability to experience solidarity with such technologies, due to the recognition that technologies serve roles in society functionally equivalent to the social roles of humans.

Presenters
Nolen Gertz
Kind of session / presentation

Struggles for Recognition in the Age of AI

Struggles for Recognition in the Age of AI

Recognition, in a philosophical sense, refers to the familiar notion of depending on the affirmation of others for one’s social identity in coexistence. While respect for people’s rights, esteem for accomplishments, and love for emotional needs are seen as exemplary forms of such affirmations, actions of disregard are seen as threats to that end. Recognition theory traces its roots to the work of German idealist Georg W. F. Hegel and was revived in the 1990s by leading philosophers like Charles Taylor, Axel Honneth, and Nancy Fraser.

Organizers
Rosalie Waelen
Christopher Senf
Kind of session / presentation

Climate justice, environmental ethics, and the global ecological crisis

Climate justice, environmental ethics, and the global ecological crisis

Despite the shared focus of climate ethics, environmental ethics, and political theory on threats to the natural environment and human well-being, these discourses have developed into largely isolated fields. One dividing line of thought is the ethical consideration of non-human entities, which is a key topic in environmental ethics, but is often side-stepped in climate ethics in favour of justice for human beings.

Organizers
Dominic Lenzi
Alexandria Poole
Kind of session / presentation