The Argumentation within Values: For a Dialectics of Value-Based Technology Design
One would be excused to think that values are just “bullshit” - to use the philosophical term successfully brought from slang into philosophy by Harry Frankfurt (Frankfurt 2005). This is because both values (e.g., liberty, equality, justice) and meta-values (e.g., Ruth Chang’s parity, Michael Walzer’s complex equality) underdetermine the design process and can even be applied contradictorily on the same decision. For example, one and the same technology can be described as sustainable and not-sustainable, as serving/promoting and not promoting freedom.